Time management and planning

The planning fallacy: why everything takes longer than you think

Published 8 min read
The planning fallacy: why everything takes longer than you think: an illustrated guide from Taskling, the ADHD daily planner

The planning fallacy is our habit of underestimating how long our own tasks will take, even when similar tasks ran late before. It was named by psychologists Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky and tested in a famous study of students writing their theses. Everyone does it, but combined with ADHD time blindness it can make every day feel like a failure. The fix is to plan using your past, not your hopes, and to break tasks into parts before estimating.

Key takeaways
  • People underestimate their own task time but not other people's.
  • In a classic study, students took far longer on their thesis than they predicted.
  • We imagine the plan and forget the interruptions that always happen.
  • Break tasks into steps, check past durations, and add a buffer.

What the planning fallacy is

You plan to clean the kitchen in 20 minutes. It takes an hour. You plan to finish an application in an afternoon. It takes four evenings. You knew this from last time, and you still believed this time would be different. That is the planning fallacy: a predictable optimism about our own timelines that survives repeated evidence against it.

Psychologists Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky gave it its name in 1979. Kahneman later told the story of a textbook project his own team expected to finish in about two years. It took eight.

Quote card from the Taskling guide The planning fallacy: why everything takes longer than you think: The planning fallacy is our habit of underestimating how long our own tasks will take, even when similar tasks ran late before.
From the guide “The planning fallacy: why everything takes longer than you think”

The thesis study

In 1994, Roger Buehler, Dale Griffin and Michael Ross asked 37 psychology students to predict when they would finish their honours thesis. The average estimate was 33.9 days. The average actual time was 55.5 days, and only about 30 percent finished by the date they predicted. Even their worst case predictions were too optimistic on average.

The researchers found people underestimated their own completion times but not those of others. When asked to think aloud, people mostly described how the task would go, step by step. Few mentioned how earlier projects had actually gone. We picture the plan, not the interruptions, the low energy days and the steps we forgot existed.

Why it hits harder with ADHD

The planning fallacy affects everyone. ADHD adds two things. The first is time blindness, a weaker felt sense of time passing, which makes estimates even more of a guess. The second is extra friction: getting started, switching tasks and recovering from distractions all take time that rarely appears in a plan.

The result is the classic ADHD to do list: twelve items planned, three done, and a feeling of failure at the end of the day. The problem was not the effort. It was the plan.

How to plan more realistic days

  1. Break it down before you estimate. Research on the planning fallacy suggests listing the steps of a task can make estimates more realistic. "Clean the kitchen" becomes dishes, counters, floor and rubbish.
  2. Use your own history. Time a task once and write it down. Next time, plan using that number, not your feeling.
  3. Add a buffer. A simple rule: add half again to your estimate. If you think 40 minutes, plan an hour.
  4. Ask an outsider. Others estimate your tasks more realistically. Ask a friend how long they think it will take.
  5. Plan fewer things. Pick three tasks for the day and treat anything extra as a bonus.
  6. Plan in parts of the day, not minutes. Morning, afternoon and evening give flexibility that a minute by minute schedule cannot.
  7. Review the day. Notice which tasks ran over. That data makes tomorrow's plan better.
Try it in Taskling

Taskling splits your day into anytime, morning, afternoon and evening instead of rigid time slots, so a task that runs long does not break the whole plan. Ask Tadaa to break a big task into steps, and see each one with its own estimate. See how task breakdown works.

Quick answers

Is the planning fallacy the same as time blindness?

No. The planning fallacy is a general bias in estimating. Time blindness is a weaker sense of time passing, often described in ADHD. They add up.

Why do I estimate other people's tasks better?

When looking at others, you naturally think about how things usually go, including delays. For your own tasks, you imagine the ideal plan.

Does a buffer not just make me slower?

Usually not. A buffer makes the plan match reality, so you finish on time more often and feel less behind.